1

What is U-Factor Times Area Value in Cooling Towers

A basic question. What is U-Factor Times Area Value in CoolingTower:* objects?

  1. What area is the area? The total surface area of the cooling tower packing? The apparent area of the packing? The total air inlet opening area? Or the total air outlet opening area?
  2. The unit is [W/K]. The K seems to be a temperature difference, but where is it? The difference between the OA WB and the inlet water temperature? Between the OA WB and the outlet water temperature? Or between the water inlet temperature and outlet temperature?
Keigo's avatar
4k
Keigo
asked 2024-08-15 00:55:38 -0500, updated 2024-08-15 01:02:53 -0500
edit flag offensive 0 remove flag close merge delete

Comments

add a comment see more comments

1 Answer

1

For EnergyPlus questions like this, if the Input Output Reference doesn't provide details, then the Engineering Reference is likely your best documentation option. In this case, the section describing Cooling Towers and Evaporative Fluid Coolers has a description of variable-speed vs. "other" (one-, two-, and variable-speed) cooling tower models. The "other" cooling tower model description shows the following equation.

Cooling Tower Model Description

  1. Area is "heat transfer surface area", which is usually the area of the surface(s) that separate the two fluids exchanging heat (air and water, in this case). It's definitely not the opening area, but I'm not sure what you mean by "packing". Diagrams I've seen use terms like "fill media", "distribution surface", or "exchange surface" for the component where air and water interact within a cooling tower.

  2. As you see above, the original equation uses an ENTHALPY difference divided by air's specific heat to calculate heat transfer. This is why the $UA$ parameter has a temperature unit. If you follow the rest of the model description, going through all the assumptions and derived heat transfer calculations, you'll eventually get to the heat exchanger effectiveness equations below that relate $UA$ to three temperatures:

  • inlet water temperature
  • outlet water temperature
  • inlet air wet-bulb

image description

Aaron Boranian's avatar
14.1k
Aaron Boranian
answered 2024-08-15 10:51:04 -0500
edit flag offensive 0 remove flag delete link

Comments

Thanks for your answer. I understand it.

Cooling tower packing refers to the same thing as "fill media", "distribution surface" or "exchange surface".

Expanding the expression for cooling tower effectiveness you attached, we get the following equation for UAe:

UAe = Cw[log(1-εCw/Ca) - log(1-ε)] / [1-(Cw/Ca)]

I guess no one calculates the equation. UA is a parameter unique to EnergyPlus. IESVE does not have it. It is not provided by mechanical engineers and cooling tower suppliers. So, EnergyPlus developers do not expect users to hardsize it. It is normally autosized. Is that correct?

Keigo's avatar Keigo (2024-08-17 00:41:23 -0500) edit

@Keigo users have the option to hard-size or autosize cooling tower UA according to the performance input method(default is hard-size UA).

If hard-sizing UA, you also hard-size water flow and air flow.

If autosizing UA, you need to hard-size nominal capacity and free convection capacity.

Aaron Boranian's avatar Aaron Boranian (2024-08-20 12:08:38 -0500) edit

@Aaron Boranian I know the options. I'm curious about the developers' intention and what users normally do.

Let me change my question. Have you ever hardsized cooling tower UA?

Keigo's avatar Keigo (2024-08-20 19:43:39 -0500) edit
add a comment see more comments